Shadow Cabinet Slams 400B Loan Decree for Long-Term Projects

Thansettakij•Economy•20d ago

Reader Briefing

Shadow Cabinet criticizes the government's 400 billion baht loan decree, alleging it aims to boost popularity rather than provide genuine relief, and questions the inclusion of long-term projects without parliamentary review.

•The Thai Shadow Cabinet has strongly criticized the government's 400 billion baht loan decree, passed by the Cabinet.
•Key concerns include the decree's alleged use of funds for popular but financially unsustainable projects like 'Kon La Krueng' and the inclusion of long-term economic restructuring projects without proper parliamentary debate.
•The Shadow Cabinet also raised concerns about the proposed Land Bridge project, citing financial unviability and potential geopolitical risks, and expressed reservations about the Southern Economic Corridor (SEC) bill potentially granting excessive powers and legal exemptions.

Overview

•The Shadow Cabinet, represented by Sirikanya Tansakul, has expressed strong reservations about the government's 400 billion baht loan decree.
•Sirikanya Tansakul stated that aid measures have been insufficient, not widely covered, and overly minimal, failing to target groups like the transport and fishing sectors effectively.
•Sirikanya Tansakul noted that 200 billion baht of the loan is allocated for a one-time distribution within 4 months, primarily for the 'Kon La Krueng' project.
•The government's use of loan funds for the 'Kon La Krueng' project is questioned, with the Shadow Cabinet suggesting it may be an attempt to gain popularity rather than provide genuine relief.
•Sirikanya Tansakul indicated no objection to the 200 billion baht loan for direct relief but expressed concern over the 200 billion baht for long-term economic restructuring, arguing it does not require an emergency decree.
•The Shadow Cabinet proposed that long-term projects should be presented as a bill (พ.ร.บ.) for parliamentary consideration, which could be enacted within approximately three months.
•Weerayuth Kanchuchatt highlighted that the Land Bridge project's financial viability is questionable, with a low financial internal rate of return (FIRR) of 4.9% and a net present value (NPV) deficit of 42 billion baht.
•Khomnan Noonanan criticized the Southern Economic Corridor (SEC) bill for concentrating power and creating legal exemptions, similar to issues seen in the Eastern Economic Corridor (EEC) project.

Full article content is available on the original source.

Read on Thansettakij (Thai Version)View in Google Translate

Source: Thansettakij (Original)

Key Quotes

Sirikanya Tansakul

"The question is, if the war doesn't end and energy prices remain high, what will the government do? Will it need to borrow more funds?"

คำถามคือหากหลังจากนี้สงครามยังไม่จบ ราคาพลังงานยังอยู่ในระดับสูง รัฐบาลจะทำอย่างไร ต้องกู้เงินก้อนใหม่อีกหรือไม่

Sirikanya Tansakul

"Therefore, it can be seen that using loans for the "Kon La Krueng" project is not intended to compensate the public, but rather to borrow popularity for the declining government?"

จึงมองได้ว่าการใช้เงินกู้ไปกับโครงการคนละครึ่ง ไม่ได้ตั้งใจจะเยียวยาประชาชน แต่กำลังใช้เงินกู้ เพื่อกู้คะแนนนิยมของรัฐบาลที่กำลังตกต่ำหรือไม่

Sirikanya Tansakul

"But the loan for plan 2, another 200 billion baht for long-term economic restructuring, such as supporting energy efficiency,"

แต่เงินกู้ตามแผนงานที่ 2 อีกจำนวน 2 แสนล้านบาทเพื่อปรับโครงสร้างเศรษฐกิจระยะยาว ไม่ว่าจะเป็นการสนับสนุนการใช้พลังงานให้เกิดประสิทธิภาพ

Weerayut Kanchuchatt

"If considering only financial worth, the latest report from the Office of Transport and Policy Planning clearly states this project is not worth investing in."

หากพิจารณาจากความคุ้มค่าทางการเงินเพียงอย่างเดียว รายงานจากสำนักงานนโยบายและแผนการขนส่งและจราจร (สนข.) ฉบับล่าสุดชี้ชัดว่าโครงการนี้ไม่คุ้มค่าต่อการลงทุน

Khomnan Noonanan

"It has characteristics of absolute centralized power and creates an exemption system within the law."

มีลักษณะเป็นการรวมอำนาจแบบเบ็ดเสร็จเด็ดขาด และสร้างระบบยกเว้นทางกฎหมายขึ้นมา

Key Entities

Organization

Shadow Cabinet(ครม.เงา)

A parallel cabinet formed by the opposition, tasked with scrutinizing and critiquing government policies.

People's Party(พรรคประชาชน)

The opposition political party to which Sirikanya Tansakul and Weerayut Kanchuchatt belong.

Cabinet(คณะรัฐมนตรี)

The executive body of the Thai government responsible for approving decrees and policies.

Ministry of Finance(กระทรวงการคลัง)

The government ministry responsible for managing state finances, including borrowing and loan decrees.

Office of Transport and Policy Planning (OTP)(สำนักงานนโยบายและแผนการขนส่งและจราจร (สนข.))

A Thai government agency responsible for planning and policy development in the transportation sector, which provided a report on the Land Bridge project's financial feasibility.

Person

Sirikanya Tansakul(น.ส.ศิริกัญญา ตันสกุล)ℹ️

Deputy Leader of the People's Party and Head of the Shadow Cabinet's Public Sector Reform Team, a vocal critic of the government's economic policies.

Weerayut Kanchuchatt(นายวีระยุทธ กาญจน์ชูฉัตร)

Deputy Leader of the People's Party and Head of the Shadow Cabinet's New Economy Team, who analyzes the financial viability of large infrastructure projects.

Khomnan Noonanan(น.ส.คมน หนุนอนันต์)

Spokesperson for the People's Party, who commented on the concerning aspects of the Southern Economic Corridor (SEC) Act.

Law

400 Billion Baht Loan Decree(พรก.เงินกู้ 4 แสนล้าน)

A government decree authorizing the Ministry of Finance to borrow 400 billion baht to address energy crisis impacts and energy transition.

Kon La Krueng Project(โครงการคนละครึ่ง)

A government stimulus project involving a co-payment scheme to support consumer spending, criticized by the Shadow Cabinet as a broad, inefficient use of loan funds.

Southern Economic Corridor (SEC) Act(พ.ร.บ.ระเบียงเขตเศรษฐกิจภาคใต้ (SEC))

A proposed legal framework for developing economic zones in southern Thailand, criticized by the Shadow Cabinet for potentially concentrating power and creating legal exemptions.

Eastern Economic Corridor (EEC)(เขตพัฒนาพิเศษภาคตะวันออก (EEC))

A government initiative focused on developing advanced economic zones in Thailand's eastern provinces, used as a point of comparison for the SEC Act's potential issues.